Self-Tanner

Is it possible to be SO pale that your skin rejects even tanning with self-tanner?

I think it is.

I first tried the Neutrogena Spray. FAIL.

Now I've been trying the Neutrogena Build-a-Tan. I'm halfway through the bottle and I'm think I MAY be seeing a little hint of tan (however, it could just be the lighting - yep, I think it's the lighting.)

UGH.

I don't even want to be dark. I just want to NOT be pasty white.